6 Dec 2024

Matt Mullenweg Signed WordPress Foundation Trademark Application as “CEO”, Despite Not Being Its CEO

Former direct employee of Matt Mullenweg, Samuel Sidler, wrote an interesting post about the unclear ownership of the Openverse, which is a WordPress project. One piece of the story ties into something we have looked at. The extent that the WordPress Foundation is intertwined with Automattic, especially with trademark applications. He wrote this:

The application of the wordmark was made by the WordPress Foundation, with Mullenweg signing the paperwork with a title of “CEO.”[9] Meanwhile, on the trademark application for the logo, Mullenweg signed the paperwork with a title of “Founder.” On November 10, 2022, Chloe Bringmann—with a title of “Chief of Staff”—signed a “statement of use” for the logo, noting first use was July 20, 2021. Bringmann signed a “statement of use” for the wordmark on May 23, 2023, noting first use was April 27, 2021. [Read more]

23 Oct 2024

The WordPress Must Win Open Letter Pretends That WordPress’ Lack of Independent Governance Isn’t Intentional

WordPress has a significant problem with toxic positivity. We have seen that over and over in the security space. Where trying to have a discussion about problems and how they could be fixed leads to criticism for bringing up the problems. That not only means problems don’t get resolved, but it helps out those taking advantage of the WordPress community. Along those lines, the latest WP Weekly newsletter mentioned “a petition calling for the creation of strong WordPress Foundation v2″ called WordPress Must Win. The letter is described as an “appeal to divert all energy being wasted in fights towards co-creating a fully independenttransparent, and strong WordPress Foundation v2.” It doesn’t address the big problem with that proposal, WordPress doesn’t have that independent and transparent governance because the person in control of WordPress, Matt Mullenweg, doesn’t want that.

Here is how they described the WordPress Foundation v2: [Read more]

23 Oct 2024

Matt Mullenweg Is Complaining That WP Engine Hasn’t Donated to the WordPress Foundation, Despite It Having Too Much Money

Trust is a big part of security and trust is in short supply with the head of WordPress these days. He keeps saying things that are problematic. At the top are the outright lies to highly misleading statements. One of his arguments against WP Engine had been problematic before and then got more problematic late last week.

Recently, the Trademark Policy page of the WordPress Foundation was updated to include this message about WP Engine: [Read more]

22 Oct 2024

Minutes of WordPress Foundation 2024 Meeting Highlight How Intertwined It Is With Automattic

In a cease and desist letter dated September 23, a lawyer from Perkins Coie wrote that they were writing while representing “Automattic Inc. and WooCommerce, Inc.” One section of that was titled “Violations of Our WordPress Foundation Trademark Policy” and has this information under the heading:

It is further inappropriate that you violated the terms of your WordCamp US Sponsorship Agreement, which specified clearly that “any use of the WordPress trademarks is subject to the WordPress Trademark Policy listed at http://wordpressfoundation.org/trademark-policy.” You repeatedly and intentionally violated the WordPress Foundation Trademark Policy’s prohibition on the “use [of] the[] [WordPress marks] as part of a product, project, service, domain name, or company name,” as demonstrated in Exhibit B attached hereto. [Read more]

17 Oct 2024

Was the WordPress Foundation Just Matt Mullenweg When It Issued Him a License for the WordPress Trademark?

As part of Matt Mullenweg’s attempt to post through his own bad actions, earlier this week he was criticizing people behind a couple of other open source projects over the ownership of the trademarks. He wrote this:

Let’s talk about trademarks! I don’t own the WordPress trademark personally, it belongs to a foundation on which I’m one of three votes. Rails? [Read more]

15 Oct 2024

Matt Mullenweg Claims He Doesn’t Know about Day to Day Operations of the WordPress Foundation, Who Does?

So far, with everything going on with WordPress, there has been a decided lack of new details exposed by journalists. There have been plenty of stories, but most just repeating claims made by various parties in the situation. That changed today, as TechCrunch’s Ivan Mehta reported on an internal Automattic blog post that laid out the strategy of trying to gain more control over the WordPress trademark. Here is part of how he described that:

The message – penned by Automattic’s then-chief legal officer Paul Sieminski in January 2024 on the company’s “P2” (a version of WordPress aimed at internal communications) – outlined a plan for how Automattic would approach this strategy, through direct negotiations with companies and via legal action from “nice and not nice lawyers and trademark enforcers.” And Automattic potentially would register further trademarks going forward. [Read more]

9 Oct 2024

Matt Mullenweg Claims the WordPress Trademark Was Donated to the WordPress Foundation, Automattic’s Lawyer Disagrees

The trademark for WordPress plays an important role in Matt Mullenweg’s extortion campaign against WP Engine, and all the security implications that come out of it. What is clear is how unclear things have been with that. Matt Mullenweg has said things that are misleading and in other cases appear to be outright false. One of his own lawyers is disagreeing with him over fundamental issue (it isn’t the only issue they disagree with him). Was the trademark donated to the WordPress Foundation or not?

Matt Mullenweg’s announcement in 2010 said the trademark was donated (emphasis ours): [Read more]

7 Oct 2024

WordPress Foundation’s Recent Hosting Related Trademark Filings List Automattic Employee as Its Chief of Staff

The recent interview that Matt Mullenweg did with The Verge highlighted his focus on WP Engine having not donated to the WordPress Foundation. It is an odd focus since the WordPress Foundation does almost nothing and he hasn’t explained why it would need more money. There is also an issue that the foundation appears to largely operate as an arm of Matt Mullenweg’s for-profit company, Automattic. That is the entity he has been trying to extort WP Engine through.

As we noted before, the foundation’s blog is being written exclusively by Automattic employees. Those employees claim that they are spending 40 hours a week working on WordPress, which is separate from the WordPress Foundation. They are not alone in that. [Read more]

3 Oct 2024

Matt Mullenweg Is Claiming His License From the WordPress Foundation for the WordPress Trademark Is All Public, the License Isn’t Public

When we last covered Matt Mullenweg’s claims about the WordPress trademark, we focused on his claim in an interview that the licenses the WordPress Foundation has with Automattic and him are revocable. That runs counter the publicly available license for Automattic, which says that it is “perpetual, irrevocable.” We also noted that the WordPress Foundation hasn’t published any the licenses it has with anyone on their website. The Automattic license is available through the United States Patent and Trademark Office’s website.

That makes a response he provided on the Hacker News after WP Engine filed a lawsuit highlighted his misleading claims about the trademark situation stand out: [Read more]

3 Oct 2024

Automattic is Now Claiming That a Non-Profit Other Than the WordPress Foundation Controls WordPress and WordPress.org

There continues to be confusion over who or what actually owns WordPress and the associated wordpress.org website. Considering what has happened recently, the ownership is a big security issue. Adding to the confusion was a post published yesterday on the website of Automattic, which is headed by Matt Mullenweg. Matt Mullenweg is claiming to personally own WordPress.org. The post by Neil Peretz, an associate general counsel at Automattic is titled WordPress Trademarks: A Legal Perspective. It makes this claim:

The Foundation also licensed the name WordPress to the non-profit WordPress.org, which runs a website that facilitates access to WordPress-related software. [Read more]